
What Size Water Heater Do You Need? Tank and Tankless
Updated
Get a free quote
A licensed plumber replies with a price. Nothing is booked until you say yes.
Rather talk? Call (608) 927-6750 or text us.
Short answer
Part of Tankless Water Heaters.
Picking a water heater size comes down to how much hot water the house needs at its busiest, not how many people live there. If you are weighing a tank against an on-demand unit, see tankless water heater installation for the model that heats water as you use it. This guide covers how to size either type and what Wisconsin's plumbing code requires of the installation.
Sizing a tank water heater for a household
Cost guides describe the standard replacement as a 40 or 50 gallon tank (HomeAdvisor). The right choice is the one that covers your peak demand without running out. Think about the busiest hour of your week: several showers, a dishwasher cycle and a load of laundry, all within an hour. A tank that cannot keep up in that hour runs cold, and one that is too large costs more and keeps more water hot than you use.
Use these questions to size it.
- How many people shower in the same morning, and how long do the showers run?
- Do you run a dishwasher or washer while someone showers?
- Do you have a large soaking tub or a high-flow shower head?
- Does the household have guests, or is it growing or shrinking?
A one or two person household with short showers often does well on the smaller size. A larger household with overlapping use is where a 50 gallon tank earns its price. Treat these as rules of thumb; a plumber can size from your actual habits.
The first hour rating
The number to compare is not the tank size alone. The manufacturer's label lists a first hour rating, which is how much hot water the heater can deliver in a busy hour starting from a full tank, counting both what is stored and what the burner or elements heat while you draw water. Two 50 gallon heaters can have different first hour ratings, so check the label, not the capacity. A heater with a higher recovery rate heats incoming water faster, which matters if the house has many people showering back to back.
40 gallon versus 50 gallon
| 40 gallon | 50 gallon | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical fit | Smaller households, shorter showers | Larger households, overlapping use |
| Typical installed cost | $800 to $2,300 | $800 to $2,500 |
| Footprint | Slightly shorter or narrower | A little taller or wider, check the closet |
| Watch for | Running out when use overlaps | Higher standby heat loss |
The cost spread between the two is small, so the size decision should follow your use, not the price. Check that the larger tank fits the space, since a basement closet or a low ceiling can limit the choice. The overall range for a standard tank installed is $881 to $1,826, with an average of $1,348 (HomeAdvisor). See the plumber cost page for how this compares with other jobs.
Sizing a tankless water heater in Wisconsin
A tankless heater has no storage tank, so its size is a flow rate: how many gallons per minute it can heat to the temperature you set. Two things decide that number. One is how many fixtures run at once. The other is how much the water has to be warmed, which depends on how cold the incoming water is. Beloit's water comes from groundwater, and groundwater runs cold in winter, so the heater has more heating to do in January than in July. A unit sized for summer can fall short in the cold months, so the plumber sizes it for the winter case.
Tankless installs cost a typical $1,404 to $3,904, with an average near $2,641. Cost guides give unit-only prices of $500 to $2,200 for gas and $100 to $800 for electric, depending on size (Angi). A gas unit may need a larger gas line and new venting. A venting change alone can add roughly $500 to $1,500 (HomeGuide). Hard water also scales the heat exchanger of a tankless heater, so Beloit's mineral content is worth a look before you buy; see how hard Beloit water is.
What Wisconsin code requires for a water heater install
Wisconsin's plumbing code sets the basics in SPS 382.40 (SPS 382.40). A pressurized storage heater needs a combination temperature and pressure relief valve rated at or above the heater's input, with no shutoff valve between the heater and the relief valve (SPS 382.40(5)(d)). The discharge pipe cannot be trapped, cannot have a valve in it and must drain by gravity to a floor drain or receptor, ending within 6 inches above the floor.
A heater serving a closed water system also needs an expansion tank or another approved device to control thermal expansion, though an instantaneous non-storage heater is exempt. If a relief valve drips, see the relief valve guide and the expansion tank guide. Where the permit side is concerned, read permits for water heaters and pipe work.
Signs your current water heater is the wrong size
- Hot water runs out in the middle of a normal shower, which suggests the tank or its recovery is too small for the way the house is used.
- The house has changed since the heater went in: a bathroom added, a household that grew or a large tub installed.
- The tank is much larger than anyone needs and hot water sits unused for long stretches, which wastes energy on standby heat.
- The heater is old and rumbles, leaks or shows rust at the base, which is a replacement conversation more than a sizing one.
Bring the old heater's label to the plumber if you can. It lists the capacity, the input rating and the model, which makes the swap simpler. Fuel matters too: switching from gas to electric, or back, changes the cost and may need a new circuit or venting, and a like-for-like swap is usually the cheaper job.
Choosing between a tank and a tankless
A tank is the lower upfront cost and the simplest swap, which is why it is the common replacement. A tankless unit costs more to install but takes less floor space and does not run out during one long shower. A heat pump model, covered in the heat pump water heater guide, costs the most upfront and uses less electricity. The water heater overview on the homepage compares the three. The best choice depends on your space, your fuel and your budget, and a plumber can quote all three for the same house.
Want a price for your own house?
Call, text, or send the form. You get a price back before any work is scheduled.
Quick answers
What size water heater do I need for a family?
Most replacements are 40 or 50 gallons, and the better guide is the first hour rating on the label, which shows how much hot water the heater delivers in a busy hour. List your peak use, such as showers plus a dishwasher, and size to that. A plumber can check it against your actual habits.
Is a 50 gallon water heater too big for two people?
A larger tank costs a little more and holds more hot water than a small household may use, which adds standby heat loss. If showers rarely overlap, 40 gallons often covers it. Installed prices for both sizes overlap, see the cost page.
How much does a new water heater cost to install?
A standard tank water heater runs about $881 to $1,826 installed, with an average near $1,348. A tankless unit runs about $1,404 to $3,904. Details and sources are on the cost page.
Does a tankless water heater work in cold Wisconsin winters?
Tankless heaters work in Wisconsin, but they have to heat colder incoming water in winter, so they should be sized for the winter case. A plumber sizes the flow rate to your fixtures and your coldest water. Skipping that step is the usual cause of lukewarm showers.
Does Wisconsin require a relief valve on a water heater?
Pressurized storage heaters need a combination temperature and pressure relief valve under SPS 382.40, with a discharge pipe that is not trapped and has no valve in it. A closed water system also needs an expansion tank or similar device for thermal expansion.
How long does a water heater last?
Lifespans vary with water quality, maintenance and the unit. In Beloit, hard water leaves scale in a tank and can shorten that life, so flushing the tank from time to time helps. A plumber can check the condition during a visit.
Want a plumber to look at it?
Describe the problem and the town. A licensed plumber replies with a price before any work starts.
Prices and the full service list are on the homepage for a plumber in Beloit.
